HN Companion◀︎ back | HN Companion home | new | best | ask | show | jobs
Ask HN: Where are you on the spectrum of AI/LLM adoption?
3 points by joddystreet 19 hours ago | 7 comments
- Personal user (not using in work)

- Auto-complete only

- Adopted agents, write specs + reviews code

- Adopted agents, write specs, no code review

- Adopted agents, no specs, no code review

- Moved back from agents to Auto-complete only

- Moved away from LLMs altogether



I'm still back at the question of what goals we are trying to achieve in the first place. Much of the software dev industry jumped straight to "automating coding is the goal", and I haven't yet agreed with that conclusion. Speeding it up? Sure. Doing the tedious work, implementing known algorithms, sure. Finding your way around unfamiliar codebases, yes. We could list more - there are plenty of great use cases, and I partake of them.

But the biggest value I have ever seen offered by individuals in the software industry comes in the form of institutional knowledge. The kind that allows some of us to hear about a few odd symptoms, think it through in our head, and immediately narrow down the problem space we need to troubleshoot into something small and manageable. Or can hear about a potential refactor and spit out a quick list of impacts it would have to the system in a few minutes on a call. Can LLMs do that? Maybe. Should they? I'm not so sure. If they can do in seconds what a human can do in days/weeks, that is clearly valuable. If they do in seconds what a human can do in minutes, that is less valuable. I lean towards a belief that human holders of the knowledge is a good thing, but LLMs could absolutely assist with knowledge transfer and sharing, making even more people able to work at that level. I'm simply unconvinced that outsourcing all that to LLMs is desirable.

I am 100% convinced that massive amounts of work, efforts, infrastructure build-out, and money could get LLMs to that point. But my question remains because that same level of resources could also do so many other things for our society. So I'm not stuck on "What could LLMs do?", I'm stuck on "What society do we want to live in?", and not at all convinced that the AI-pilled "AI can do it all" world is desired, even if it is possible.


I am working with ai coding already almost 1 year, and actually every new week i learn so many new cool things, but also i understand so much more things i did not know yet and did not use, than i thought half a year ago. So actually i can tell, that half year ago i thought that my level 7 of 10, but now i even not sure that my level at least 5, even i know x10 times more than i knew half a year ago.

A huge portion of my career has been making this technology possible.

I watch in dismay as 95% of the software industry misunderstands and follow bullying leaders that misunderstand just as badly. Pile it deeper, all the bullshit, you can't see. This industry is a shit show of bullies, idiots and a very small population of competent and very overworked.

AI is not an automation technology, it is a communications technology in a civilization that does not understand or value quality communications, they'd rather listen to some fool telling them nice things, while leading them to disaster.

I've been training models since before the term training as adopted, and I have a comprehensive AI integrated environment that enables me to operate very optimally.


I’m still farting around writing my own AC.. but I actually have a budget to mess around. My agents are getting better at reviewing others PRs, but aren’t exactly dialed in yet. Still toying with larger epic and story creation efforts. Having a hard time letting go control.


Seeking AI/LLM to automate tedious tasks in a way that gives consistent, near repeatable results, eg paper evaluation, summarizing articles, auditing code.

spending 23% my tokens and 8 hours of my day to generate 3.3 seconds of video

https://github.com/tnn1t1s/tnn1t1s-comfy/tree/main/examples/...